Building Thought Through Conversations

Censorship

CENSORSHIP

Perhaps the importance of our freedom of speech is better understood if we remember that when our thoughts remain in our minds and we are not allowed to express them in action or in speech, then those thoughts remain embryonic and incomplete.  To express a thought is to work out the complete thought–to bring the thought to fruition.  Not only do ideas not reach full maturation if they are left unexpressed, but they also do not, paradoxically, become fully a part of the speaker’s mind.  An unexpressed thought is a thought not clearly known by the thinker.

 Everyone knows what it is like to say something aloud to someone else that you had only previously thought: suddenly the thought is real and powerful and the knowledge of that thought becomes a part of the identity of the person speaking, not only new knowledge on the part of the person hearing the speech.  In those moments, after we have spoken something that we had never had the courage to speak before, we redefine ourselves to be in accordance with that thought: “I am the person who thinks so-and-so.”   In other words, when we express ourselves we not only let others know our thoughts, but we come to know those thoughts as well.  Self-expression is self-knowledge.


ConverseThoughts: The Artwork

Presented in conjunction with an exhibition held at Kitchen Table Gallery Philadelphia entitled More Stately Mansions.

Dena Shottenkirk, Destruction of the Artifacts: Homage to the Bamiyan Buddhas (2013-14) oil on canvas, 60 x 72 x 2 1/4 in.

 
Dena Shottenkirk. The Destruction of Artifacts. oil on canvas, 2013-14, 60 in. x 72 in. x 2 1/4 in.

Detail of Destruction of the Artifacts: Homage to the Bamiyan Buddhas (2013-14) oil on canvas, 60 x 72 x 2 1/4 in.

DETAIL: Dena Shottenkirk. Destruction of the Artifacts: Homage to the Bamiyan Buddhas (2013-14) oil on canvas, 60 x 72 x 2 1/4 in.

Dena Shottenkirk. Women Censored: Anger. (2013 & 2021), oil on panel with hinges and handle 16 x 13 in., wooden box with paper slips, 8 x 12 x 6 in.

Dena Shottenkirk. Women Censored: Anger. (2013 & 2021), oil on panel with hinges and handle, 16 x 13 in., wooden box with paper slips, 8 x 12 x 6 in.

Installation view (opened)

Detail of Women Censored: Anger. (2013 & 2021), oil on panel with hinges and handle, 16 x 13 in

Detail of paper slips pulled from Women Censored: Anger. (2013 & 2021) wooden box with paper slips, 8 x 12 x 6 in.

Dena Shottenkirk. Women Censored: Pensiveness. (2013 & 2021), oil on panel, 16 x 13 in., wooden box with paper slips, 8 x 12 x 6 in. hinges and handle

Detail of paper slips pulled from Women Censored: Pensiveness. (2013 & 2021)

Dena Shottenkirk. Women Censored: Pensiveness. (2013 & 2021), oil on panel with hinges and handle 16 x 13 in.

Installation detail (left panel opened)

Dena Shottenkirk. Women Censored: Pensiveness. (2013 & 2021), oil on panel, 16 x 13 in.

Installation detail (right panel opened)

Dena Shottenkirk. Lolita. (2013 & 2021) oil on panel with hinges and handle, 16 x 13 in., wooden box with paper slips, 8 x12 x 6 in..

Dena Shottenkirk. Lolita. (2013 & 2021) oil on panel with hinges and handle, 16 x 13 in., wooden box with paper slips, 8 x12 x 6 in..

Installation view (left panel opened)

Detail (right panel) Lolita. (2013 & 2021) oil on panel with hinges and handle 16 x 13 in.

Detail of Lolita. (2013 & 2021) oil on panel with hinges and handle, 16 x 13 in.

Installation view (left panel opened)

Dena Shottenkirk. Lolita. (2013 & 2021) wooden box with paper slips, 8 x 12 x 6 in.

Detail of paper slips containing verbal output (Converse Thoughts) from talkPOPc’s Conversation Events

Dena Shottenkirk. My Words, Your Words, Our Thoughts. (2023) Diptych oil on panels 12 x 24 in & 24 x 24 in

Dena Shottenkirk. Jealousy, Fear. Listen* (2023) Diptych oil on panels 12 x 24 in & 24 x 24 in

Dena Shottenkirk. Don’t Silence Others. (2023) Diptych oil on panels 12 x 24 in & 24 x 24 in

Dena Shottenkirk. Speak, Listen, Know. (2023) Diptych oil on panels 12 x 24 in & 24 x 24 in

Dena Shottenkirk. Silenced Hate Grows. (2023) Diptych oil on panels 12 x 24 in & 24 x 24 in

Dena Shottenkirk. Fear, Anger, Listening, Thinking. (2023) Diptych oil on panels 12 x 24 in & 24 x 24 in

Publication

Cover Up the Dirty Parts! Arts Funding, Fighting, and the First Amendment takes on directly the questions regarding not only the relationship between government funding for the arts and the political censorship involved, but also the deeper philosophical questions regarding liberty, the definition of art, the role of vague terms in language and law, and the epistemological role of both free expression and art itself. The issue of arts funding sits in the terrain of overlap between aesthetics and political philosophy and thus elicits aesthetic questions regarding the purpose of art and how art is defined, political questions regarding the nature of freedom and the role of government, and epistemological questions regarding the sources of knowledge and how it is we acquire it. As both an analytic philosopher and a practicing artist, Shottenkirk has incorporated the insights and sensitivities of both worlds in this analysis of why art is important and why freedom of expression within cultural development must be respected if we are to embrace a society able to provide the maximum degree of stimulation and safety for all its members. In this context, art is viewed as valuable both as a tool for knowledge acquisition for the individual and as a source of consensus building for the culture. As a device for consensus building, art has the role of practicing respect for differing opinions and balancing competing points of view as well as serving as self-expression for the individual. Interviews with two artists, the first of whom is an American central to the funding debates of the last few decades and the second of whom is a contemporary Iranian writer imprisoned for her writing, combine with both narrative and philosophical analysis to give a complete picture of the issues and what is at stake for all of us who care not only about art but about freedom as well. While the distinction between censorship and non-funding is explored, also analyzed is the need for tolerance in the face of offense as well as respect for others' rights and cultural differences.